I guess doggy bags are a personal preference, but I love these. Love the price, for starters. Love the thinness, which makes it easy to stuff many in a pocket. Can't even smell the scent, which is fine with me. As it happens, I love the color. But what's most important to me, here in Minnesota in the winter, is that I can get the bags open without a major struggle each time. When it's cold and I take my gloves off to pick up after my dog, I want to do it as quickly as possible. I just bought my third box of these and another box by Clean Go Pet in a different scent and color.